Hi all. Happy new year etc.. I have plenty of plans for the next 12 months but won’t go into them unlike every other person with a blog is undoubtedly doing at the moment. I want to keep this strictly useful information and me telling you I want to shift some weight, buy something or do something isn’t going to improve your lives any really is it. So here goes..
I have had an interesting problem for some months now which I have just solved albeit crudely! I have written several plugins and released them into the WordPress plugin repository as regular readers of this site might already know. What you are unlikely to know though is that in doing so all you get is an influx of support questions. I personally like these.. it gives me the illusion of helping people out whilst really knowing that it should have been right to begin with
The worst of these aforementioned support questions are to do with plugin conflicts. Cue potential threads and threads about how the ‘other guy’ did something wrong which is going to need to poor user to go to their site/forum to get it sorted before our plugins can work in harmony as they were originally intended. This isn’t the best answer to a support question and certainly won’t get you any repeat custom. In all likelihood the user will ditch the plugin he finds least useful (yours.. after all he came to you to sort it in the first place meaning yours is likely the plugin they have just installed and are playing with) and install one of the other counterparts which undoubtedly does the same job but with umpteen donate buttons plastered all over it (I won’t go into that one right now but see my previous post for my thoughts on that particular subject).
One such example of a conflict I have been getting all year. It’s to do with my Welcome Email Editor plugin. WordPress does a fair few things very well indeed but sadly there are a few where it really could improve. This is why my Welcome Email Editor plugin exists at all. Can you guess what it does? Really? Ok so it lets you edit the WordPress welcome email.. the one that gives the user their user name and password if they decide to sign up for your site. The default offering is a little dull but luckily the guys who wrote WordPress have half heartedly thought about how it can be improved. Why let plugin writers like me do it of course. Sadly they opted not to use the action and filter system which already is ingrained in the rest of WordPress (for good reason I’m sure.. likely to do with load order) but instead just wrapped the entire wp_new_user_notification function in a PHP function called function_exists. This does what it says on the tin and only declares the function if someone else (a plugin or theme) doesn’t get there first.
In most cases this system works fine when you install a plugin dedicated to editing the welcome email and leave it at that. In reality most blogs have 30+ plugins active at any one time and probability and inevitability both say that more than one person is likely to want to jump on this handy feature for their plugin or theme. This means that one of the plugins needs to go! Normally if it were two plugins designed to edit the welcome email then we would be ok.. an obvious conflict of interest but what if one were a forum or shopping cart in conjunction with my plugin? Which goes then? Well the one which provides less functionality of course which, sadly, in that example would be my little plugin.
To make it somewhat more awkward, some plugins like to call WordPress core files directly thus causing the default function for the welcome email to be called before any other plugins and therefore chucking everyone else out of the race to declare the function first. Maintenance Mode is a plugin I know which does this when the system is active although it sorts itself out when you come out of maintenance mode so not really an issue. I have just been informed of another conflict with a plugin which makes dealing with WP Ecommerce in bulk easier (and we all know that was needed years ago!). Whatever reason they have called pluggable.php for I don’t know but it means that my plugin (or any other trying to declare a function first like this (it’s more common than you think!)) won’t function.
It’s such a simple solution but it works.. to fix you just need to rename my plugin directory to something else. WordPress naming conventions make calling a plugin anything starting with ‘WP’ very trendy indeed. My plugins are all prefixed SB, my initial, for archiving more than anything else but the people who do the same with initials AA are laughing at us all right now I assure you (or not laughing but living in blissful ignorance!). Here’s the logic.. it’s really simple:
On any given page load WordPress will load it’s core files first and then look for plugins to bolt on to the system using the action/filter system. This is where the PHP files are initially ‘required’/'included’ and individual balls (controlled by the plugin writers) set in motion. WordPress keeps a list of active plugins to call in the database in the wp_options table under an imaginatively named row called ‘active_plugins’. This is an alphabetically ordered list of plugins labelled by their location beneath the plugins directory (eg: welcome-email-editor/sb_welcome_email_editor.php). It will run from top to bottom including these files. This means there is a priority order for code defined only by the fact it has a name higher up the alphabet.
So to conclude the way to get your plugin run first to avoid conflicts with other plugins just put it in a directory called something beginning with a low alphabetical letter or special character. In my case I get a conflict every few months so it’s not worth changing but I am going to recommend that the next person to mention a conflict just renames their plugin folder from welcome-email-editor to -welcome-email-editor (note the leading hyphen). Job done!
I might add that changing the name of a plugin directory once a site is live isn’t a good idea on account of some plugins storing pathing information in the DB and WordPress itself storing the fact that plugin is active or not by it’s name in the directory tree. Put plainly if I change the name of my Welcome Email Editor plugin on my own site then it will deactivate itself and I shall need to reactivate it for it to continue working. Not a huge feat but try explaining that to normal user. Cue yet more support emails.
Hope this explains an issue for one or two of you. Perhaps plugin writers will learn not to call core PHP files directly in future to make my day run more smoothly… I doubt it!